Some of the links on this page are affiliate links, which means I may earn a small commission if you make a purchase through them, at no extra cost to you. This helps support the site and allows me to continue creating helpful content.
Florence really knows how to wow you with incredible food, but I’ve seen plenty of first-time visitors end up with meals that are just okay, or, honestly, a total letdown. This city is packed with tourist-focused restaurants serving generic pasta and pizza with little soul. I’ve learned over my trips that where you eat and the kind of spot you choose can make or break your eating adventures. If you want to avoid average meals and find places locals actually love, you’re in the right place.
If you’re new to Florence, picking areas with authentic spots and focusing on restaurants with real local flavor means you’ll walk away feeling you’ve tasted a slice of Florentine life, not just a reheated lasagna. I’m sharing my best tips and some favorite picks so you can dig into the best Florence has to offer, without getting trapped in high-priced tourist restaurants.
What Makes a Good Restaurant in Florence?
Florence is full of places to eat, but only some really deliver that genuine Tuscan warmth and flavor. Here’s what I pay attention to before sitting down anywhere new:
- Menus with Local Dishes: Menus should highlight classics like ribollita or pappa al pomodoro. When I see mostly generic pizza or spaghetti carbonara (which is Roman, not Florentine), I know it’s aimed at tourists.
- Smaller, More Focused Menus: The best spots usually keep their choices tight, just a few starters, several mains, and maybe a daily special or two. This means food is fresh and the kitchen isn’t spread thin.
- Good Recent Reviews: Before heading somewhere, I check what travelers are saying on sites like Google Maps or The Fork. I look for reviews talking about the food’s authenticity and the vibe, not just “nice view.”
- Away from Tourist Clusters: The closer you are to places like the Duomo or Ponte Vecchio, the more likely you’ll be charged extra for sub-par food. A short walk in any direction usually puts you in front of somewhere more genuine.
- Trattoria or Osteria Atmosphere: I always love a cozy trattoria, with wooden tables and old wine bottles on the shelf. These familyrun places feel friendly and homecooked, instead of mass produced.
For more Florence food tips, check out my full guide: What to Eat in Florence.
Best Restaurants in Florence for First-Time Visitors
Best for Bistecca alla Fiorentina
You can’t visit Florence without at least considering the famous bistecca alla Fiorentina. This monster Tbone steak is grilled to rare perfection and usually served by weight. I look for traditional steakhouses, often called “trattoria” or sometimes “ristorante”, that offer the cut as a true highlight of their menu.
Steaks are usually listed by kilogram, so don’t be caught off guard. Ask the server for the average size or what they recommend for your group. Most places won’t do individual portions, so plan to share. My personal tip: Pair your steak with a local red wine and try sides like roasted potatoes or cannellini beans. If you want the full explanation of steak ordering in Florence, I explain these traditions in my post: What Tourists Should Never Order in Italy.
Best for Traditional Tuscan Food
For a taste of Florence that goes way beyond steak, the local trattorias are where you’ll find ribollita (a hearty bread and vegetable soup), pappa al pomodoro (thick tomato bread soup), and slow cooked meats. I always keep an eye out for handwritten menus or blackboards with daily specials. If the menu’s too slick or too big, that’s usually a red flag for me.
Florentine food is simple but really sticks with you. Try dishes like peposo (a robust beef stew) or arista (Tuscan pork loin). The smaller, familyrun trattorias usually have the friendliest staff and a menu built around what’s in season. This oldschool approach always makes for a satisfying meal.
Best for Quick Lunch or Casual Bite
On busy days crisscrossing Florence’s artpacked streets, sometimes you just want something fast but still memorable. My personal go-to are schiacciata sandwich shops and bakeries scattered across the city. Schiacciata is like a Tuscan flatbread, crusty outside and soft within, split and filled with everything from cured meats to creamy cheeses and grilled veggies.
These sandwich spots are packed during lunch (especially with locals), but it’s worth standing in line. Grab a sandwich to go and eat on a stone bench or in a nearby piazza. Another great option is a pasticceria (bakery) for focaccia or a savory croissant, just the thing for fueling up between sights. For more casual eats, I list some of my favorites in Best Food Tours in Florence.
If you’d rather discover these local spots with a guide:
👉 Check Florence street food tours here
Best for Street Food
Florence has some real street food treasures, and these stands are a true test for adventurous eaters. Lampredotto, a sandwich made from slow cooked cow’s stomach, sliced and served on soft bread with salsa verde and spicy sauce, might sound extreme, but it’s a classic. You’ll spot lampredotto carts around the markets, especially near Mercato Centrale.
You’ll also find carts selling trippa (tripe) and fried snacks like coccoli (little puffs of dough with prosciutto and cheese). Even if you’re new to these, I suggest starting with lampredotto. It’s a rite of passage and surprisingly tasty. Look for a queue of locals; they know who’s doing it right!
Best for Gelato
I’ve hit up dozens of gelaterias all over Florence, and I’ve learned how to steer clear of the supersugary stuff made to catch tourists’ eyes. Real gelato shops keep things simple: muted colors, small metal tins, and seasonal flavors. If the pistachio is neongreen or the banana is bright yellow, keep looking.
Great gelaterias often display “artiginale” (artisanal) and craft everything in house. You can taste the difference. I always try flavors like nocciola (hazelnut), cioccolato fondente (dark chocolate), or something special like fig. Eating your gelato while wandering Florence’s alleys is a must. Full details are in my deeper jump in: What to Eat in Florence.
Best for Wine and Aperitivo
I’m a big fan of the Florentine tradition of aperitivo, a relaxed early evening ritual with local wine or an Aperol spritz and snacks like crostini (toasted bread with toppings), cheese, and cold cuts. Wine bars and little enotecas (wine shops) are scattered around neighborhoods like Oltrarno and Santa Croce, and they’re perfect spots to unwind.
Ask the server for Tuscan wine recommendations. Chianti Classico, Bolgheri, or sometimes a chilled Vernaccia if you want white. The snacks are usually simple but high quality. For a chill vibe, squeeze in at the bar and enjoy the afterwork crowd. Want more wine inspiration? I talk wine pairings in What to Eat in Florence.
👉 Explore Florence wine and aperitivo tours here
What to Avoid When Choosing a Restaurant in Florence
Florence’s city center pulls in travelers like a magnet, which means plenty of restaurants exist just to cash in on visitors who don’t know any better. I keep a short checklist of things to skip:
- Spots directly beside the Duomo or on the main routes from the Ponte Vecchio
- Menus with tons of color photos (especially when every dish is pictured)
- Restaurants offering every Italian dish under the sun. Florence ignores carbonara and Neapolitan pizza for a reason
- Staff hanging outside literally pulling you off the street
- Places where you see mostly tourists or groups ordered by hotel concierges; the food is usually bland and overpriced
If you’re not sure, check the reviews. And don’t be afraid to walk ten minutes away from the big sights; your meal will be far more memorable!
Best Areas to Eat in Florence
Florence’s charm isn’t just in what’s on the table, it’s also in where you’re eating. Each area of the city brings its own personality and food scene.
- Santa Croce: This neighborhood is buzzing in the evenings, with trattorias and cozy wine bars tucked onto quiet streets. It’s great for authentic Tuscan meals and a local crowd.
- Oltrarno: Just across the river, Oltrarno has a more laidback, artsy feel. You’ll find tiny osterias where the menu is dictated by what’s fresh at the market. This area is a favorite for both artisans and food lovers.
- Sant’Ambrogio: Home to Florence’s other main market, this district feels young and lively thanks to nearby universities. It’s packed with bargain spots and some of the city’s best bakeries.
- Mercato Centrale area: Around the big food market you’ll find stalls, enotecas, and street food stands with something for every craving. Upstairs at the market, there’s a modern food court with everything from truffle sandwiches to arancini.
No matter which you choose, venturing out of the tightest tourist centers always rewards you with better food and a more authentic slice of Florentine daily life. Besides, each area boasts its own food traditions, bakeries, and wine hideaways. If you want to truly get a sense of what makes Florentine cuisine unique, try exploring more than just the welltrodden city core.
Not sure where to start?
👉 Browse top-rated Florence food tours by neighborhood here
What to Order in Florence Restaurants
- Bistecca alla Fiorentina: Legendary Florentine Tbone, best shared with friends.
- Ribollita: Hearty, comforting bread vegetable stew, perfect in cooler months.
- Pappa al Pomodoro: Tomato and bread soup, simple but packed with flavor.
- Lampredotto: Traditional tripe sandwich for the adventurous eater.
- Schiacciata: Olive oilrich flatbread, either as a sandwich or torn and dipped in local olive oil.
- Tuscan wine: Chianti Classico or a local favorite from the day’s recommendations work perfectly with hearty food.
My deepdished guide for firsttimers to local food is here: What to Eat in Florence.
Food Tour Alternative
If you want to skip the guesswork and try several authentic dishes in one experience, a Florence food tour is one of the easiest options. Not only do you get to enjoy the signature local flavors, but you’ll also pick up stories and food traditions straight from seasoned guides.
👉 Check the best Florence food tours here (top-rated experiences sell out fast)
On guided food tours, you usually get to sample everything from handmade pasta and local cheese to wine, sandwiches, and gelato. These are great for figuring out what you actually love, and many guides share background stories and local food traditions you won’t read on a menu. Some tours bring you behind the kitchen scenes or include local markets, giving you an eyeopening look at Florence food culture. And if you’re short on time, there’s no better way to sample the greatest hits than with a good local guide leading you from one tasty stop to the next.
Tips for First-Time Visitors
- Book dinner reservations in advance: Florence restaurants fill up quick, especially on weekends.
- Eat a little later: Dinner often doesn’t really start till 8pm or later. If you walk in at 6pm, you’ll probably get the leftovers.
- Don’t expect free extras: The bread and cover charge (coperto) is a thing, but extras like water and sides are almost never free.
- Keep meals simple: Local dishes and daily specials almost guarantee fresher, better food. The more elaborate the menu, the less likely you’ll get anything memorable.
- Trust local specialties: You’ll sometimes see dishes you haven’t heard of. Give them a try, these are what the kitchen does best.
If you’re curious how to handle tips, see my breakdown here: Tipping in Italy Explained.
Frequently Asked Questions
Where do locals eat in Florence?
Locals usually eat in neighborhoods like Oltrarno, Santa Croce, and Sant’Ambrogio, where you’ll find small trattorias, bakeries, and wine bars serving authentic Tuscan food.
What restaurants should tourists avoid in Florence?
Avoid restaurants near major landmarks like the Duomo or Ponte Vecchio, especially those with large menus, photos of food, or staff trying to pull you inside.
Is it better to book restaurants in Florence in advance?
Yes, especially for dinner and during peak travel seasons. Popular trattorias often fill up quickly, so booking ahead is recommended.
What is the best food to try in Florence for first-time visitors?
Bistecca alla Fiorentina is the most famous dish, but you should also try ribollita, pappa al pomodoro, schiacciata sandwiches, and local Tuscan wine.
Are food tours in Florence worth it?
Yes, food tours are a great way to discover authentic local spots, avoid tourist traps, and try multiple dishes in one experience.
You can check the best Florence food tours here.
Wrapping up
Great meals in Florence don’t just happen by accident. By skipping the obvious tourist-centered restaurants and exploring local areas, you’ll eat and drink like someone who’s lived here for years. There’s a reason Florence is high on every food lover’s bucket list, and I think with a little planning you’ll agree after your first bite.
Want to avoid tourist traps and experience real Florentine food?
👉 Explore top-rated Florence food tours and book your spot early